Are you heading to Hawaii and aren’t sure which rental car to get? Keep scrolling for my honest take on whether or not it’s worth renting a convertible in Hawaii.
This post about whether or not you need a convertible in Hawaii was written by Hawaii travel expert Marcie Cheung and contains affiliate links which means if you purchase something from one of my affiliate links, I may earn a small commission that goes back into maintaining this blog.
Aloha, fellow travelers!
As a seasoned Hawaii destination expert certified by the Hawaii Tourism Authority, and someone who has explored the islands over 40 times, I’m here to help you decide if renting a convertible is the right choice for your family’s Hawaiian adventure.
Renting a car in Hawaii often presents a delightful dilemma: go practical or opt for the dreamy allure of a convertible?
Let’s jump into what you need to know, especially when traveling with kids.

Discount Hawaii Car Rental
Before I really get into the pros and cons of renting a convertible in Hawaii, I wanted to say that I usually find the best deals at Discount Hawaii Car Rental.
They get the best rates from top national companies like Alamo, Dollar, Thrifty, Avis, Enterprise, Budget, and Payless. Check out the latest prices and more details.
The Appeal of a Convertible in Hawaii
Imagine cruising along the scenic coastlines with the wind in your hair, the sun setting over the ocean, and the sweet scent of tropical flowers wafting through the air.
I mean, it’s straight out of the movies, right?

Hawaii boasts some of the world’s most beautiful drives, from the winding Road to Hana on Maui to the breathtaking vistas along the North Shore of Oahu.
A convertible can enhance these experiences, offering unobstructed views that are perfect for sightseeing and snapping photos.
Practical Considerations
Weather Factors
Hawaii’s weather, while generally beautiful, can be quite unpredictable. Sudden rain showers are common, especially on the windward sides of the islands, which could dampen your drive (quite literally).

When planning to rent a convertible, consider the time of year and the typical weather patterns of the islands you’ll be visiting.
Security Concerns
Convertibles, while stylish, do pose some security risks, particularly with the ease of access to the vehicle’s interior.

When traveling with children and the extra gear that comes with them (think strollers, diaper bags, and beach toys), securing your belongings becomes even more crucial.
Always make sure that valuables are never left in the car unattended, and be prepared to take essential items with you when you park.
Considering Kids and Car Seats
When it comes to traveling with little ones in a convertible, safety is paramount. Children must have car seats, and fitting them securely in a convertible is feasible but requires careful checking.

Not all convertibles may have the space or the appropriate fittings for certain types of car seats, so it’s essential to check this with your rental agency beforehand.
Also, consider the potential for more sun exposure in a convertible. Make sure that children are adequately protected with sunscreen and hats to shield them from the sun’s rays.
Cost Analysis
Renting a convertible typically comes at a premium compared to standard vehicles. The cost can be a significant consideration, especially for families traveling on a budget.
Fuel efficiency is another factor, as convertibles often consume more gas than more compact or economy cars, which could add up over the course of your island adventures.
Alternatives to Convertibles
For families, practicality often overrules style. Standard cars or SUVs can be more cost-effective, offer more room, and provide ample comfort for driving around the islands.

If you’re looking for a bit more adventure but with added security, consider renting a Jeep or an SUV, which are also great for exploring more rugged terrains without the security concerns of a convertible.
Tips for Renting a Vehicle in Hawaii
Book in Advance
Especially during peak travel seasons, booking your car rental in advance is crucial. This not only secures your preferred vehicle but also can lock in better rates.
Insurance and Safety
Opt for comprehensive rental insurance to cover any unforeseen circumstances. Familiarize yourself with local driving laws and always adhere to speed limits and road signs.
Suitability
Specifically for convertibles, check the trunk space and interior room to make sure it fits your family’s needs, particularly if you’re carrying car seats, booster seats, or lots of luggage.
Hawaii Car Rental FAQs
Can I fit a car seat in a convertible?
Yes, you can fit a car seat in a convertible, but make sure to check with the rental agency about the specific model to ensure it has the appropriate anchors and space for your car seat.
Is it safe to drive a convertible in Hawaii with kids?
Driving a convertible can be safe if you follow all safety guidelines, such as securing all passengers with seat belts and ensuring children are properly seated in car seats or booster seats. Always be cautious of the weather and keep valuables secured.
What should I do if it rains while I’m driving a convertible?
If rain is in the forecast, it’s a good idea to keep the convertible top up, or if it starts raining unexpectedly, pull over safely and secure the roof. Most convertibles have automatic roofs that can be closed quickly.
How much more does it cost to rent a convertible compared to a standard car?
Renting a convertible generally costs more than a standard car. The price difference can vary but expect to pay about 30-50% more for a convertible.
Are convertibles fuel-efficient?
Convertibles are not typically as fuel-efficient as compact cars, especially when driven with the top down, as this can increase air resistance and lower fuel efficiency.
How can I keep my belongings safe in a convertible?
Keep belongings safe in a convertible by not leaving valuables visible in the car when parked. Always lock the doors and take important items with you.
Is a convertible suitable for all Hawaiian islands?
A convertible can be a fun choice for any Hawaiian island, but it’s particularly enjoyable in areas with lots of scenic drives and good weather. Check local driving routes and conditions for the specific islands you plan to visit.
What are the best months to rent a convertible in Hawaii?
The best months are generally during the dry season, from April to October, when there’s less likelihood of rain and the weather is warm and sunny.
Should I rent a convertible if I’m visiting Hawaii for the first time?
If you love open-air driving and plan to explore scenic routes, a convertible can enhance your experience. However, consider your specific travel needs, budget, and the practicality of a convertible when traveling with family.
So, Should You Rent a Convertible in Hawaii?
Renting a convertible in Hawaii is undeniably tempting and can add an element of fun and freedom to your vacation that few other vehicles can match.
However, for families traveling with young children, practicality, safety, and cost are often more critical factors to consider.
Think about your family’s specific needs, your planned activities, and how much time you’ll actually spend driving versus exploring on foot or relaxing at your resort.
Whatever you decide, your trip to Hawaii will undoubtedly be memorable, filled with the stunning natural beauty and warm Aloha spirit of the islands.
Happy planning, and I look forward to hearing about your Hawaiian adventures!
Whether you choose to cruise in a convertible or not, your journey will surely be filled with breathtaking views and joyful experiences.
Looking for more Hawaii planning tips? Check out The Truth About Renting a Car in Hawaii: Mistakes You’re Making Now!, How to Plan a Trip to Hawaii: Step by Step Guide, and 5 Mistakes Moms Make When Planning Their First Hawaiian Vacation (And How to Avoid Them)!
